Divorce alimony is financial support granted to the economically weaker spouse after a divorce. The United Sections of the Court of Cassation, with their recent decision, have significantly changed how this alimony is awarded. Let's examine the key points of this ruling.
Marriage Duration
One of the primary criteria now being considered is the duration of the marriage. The United Sections have established that the longer the marriage, the more likely divorce alimony will be awarded. This marks a significant shift from previous practices where marriage duration carried less weight in the decision.
Spouses' Financial Capacity
Another crucial factor is the financial capacity of both spouses. The United Sections stipulate that the financial situation of both parties will be carefully evaluated. This means that even if one spouse was the sole financial provider, they might still be obligated to pay alimony if the other spouse is in a disadvantaged economic position.
Presence of Children
The presence of children is another relevant aspect. The United Sections have decided that when minor children are involved, divorce alimony will be more readily awarded to ensure their well-being.
How These Changes Will Affect Divorced Couples
These new criteria for awarding divorce alimony will significantly impact divorced couples in Italy. Firstly, there will be an increased need for accurate assessments of both spouses’ financial situations. It will be crucial for divorced individuals to understand that the length of the marriage and the presence of children will play a key role in determining alimony.
Furthermore, these changes may lead to greater financial equity between spouses, but they could also generate conflict during the divorce process. Therefore, it is important for divorced couples to consult with experienced family law attorneys to effectively navigate this new legislation.
In conclusion, the United Sections of the Court of Cassation have introduced important changes to the criteria for awarding divorce alimony in Italy. These changes aim to ensure greater financial equity between divorced spouses, but they may also lead to increased complexity in divorce proceedings. It is essential for divorced couples to fully understand these modifications and seek qualified legal assistance when needed.
Frequently Asked Questions
How will these changes affect my divorce case? These changes may affect your case depending on the duration of your marriage and your financial situation. Consulting a family law specialist is advisable.
What documents are needed to prove my financial situation during divorce? You will need to provide documents such as bank statements, tax returns, and any other relevant financial records.
Can I still claim alimony if we don't have children? Yes, you can still claim alimony even if there are no children involved, but other factors will influence the decision.
Do these changes apply to legal separation cases? Yes, these modifications also apply to legal separation cases.
How long will it take to get alimony under the new criteria? The time required will vary per case, but these criteria will influence the alimony decision.
The New Determination of Alimony in Light of the United Sections' Ruling No. 18287/2018
Article 5 of Law No. 898/1970 recognizes the right to receive alimony for the economically weaker spouse, meaning those who cannot meet their own needs with their financial resources.
Article 5 also specifies that the Court must consider certain essential factors, also in relation to the duration of the marriage, for the recognition and determination of alimony. These criteria include: "the conditions of the spouses, the personal and economic contribution of each to the family's management, the formation of individual or joint assets, and the income of both."
The 1990s jurisprudence (Cass. Civ. No. 11490/1990) interpreted the legal provisions by arguing that the criterion for recognizing divorce alimony should be to maintain the same standard of living enjoyed during the marriage.
In line with this approach, divorce alimony was to be granted to the spouse who, through their own financial means, could no longer maintain the same standard of living experienced during the marriage. This criterion had an attributive function regarding the an debeatur (the recognition of the right to receive alimony), while the other criteria indicated by law—"conditions of the spouses, personal and economic contribution to family management, formation of individual or joint assets, income of both"—only affected the quantum (the amount).
The Court of Cassation, with ruling No. 11504/2017 (Grilli Ruling), departed from the previous stance, establishing that the criterion for awarding divorce alimony should be the lack of independence of the requesting spouse. In other words, in this ruling, the Court of Cassation believed that the right to receive alimony should only be granted to the spouse who demonstrates an insufficient economic situation, without using the standard of living during the marriage as a benchmark.
Following this jurisprudential divergence, the Supreme Court of Cassation, United Sections, intervened with a very recent ruling (Ruling No. 18287/2018) to clarify the criteria for awarding and determining this alimony. The Court of Cassation, starting from the premise that divorce alimony should have an assistive, compensatory, and equitable nature, established the legal principle that the right to receive divorce alimony, not just its quantification, must be assessed in light of all the criteria indicated in Article 5 of Law 898/1970, superseding the previous distinction between attributive and determinative criteria.
Therefore, the right to recognition of divorce alimony presupposes insufficient financial means, to be assessed in light of "the comparative evaluation of the economic and patrimonial conditions of the parties, considering the contribution made by the applicant to the management of family life and to the formation of the joint and individual assets of each ex-spouse, in relation to the duration of the marriage and the age of the entitled party" (cf. Cass. No. 18287/2018).
By Avv. Lucia Fusari